Blog

Essays and notes: philosophy, AI, and whatever is on the desk.

Two Roles for the Appetites
Insane masters in Book 1 of the Republic , founders of the city in Book 2.

In Book 1 the appetites are insane masters to be escaped; in Book 2 they found the city. The same force that makes political community possible is the one that threatens to destroy it.

Who Founds Kallipolis?
The paradox of the just city and its first philosopher-king.

If a just soul needs a just city to form it, and a just city needs a just soul to found it, how does the cycle begin? On Plato’s exceptions for the first philosopher-king, and the deficit they leave behind.

Shadow-Virtue and Faction
Why do Plato’s degenerate regimes fall apart?

In Book 8 of the Republic every degenerate regime collapses through stasis. If Hitz’s shadow-virtues bring order, why do they all fall apart? Because they order by force, and force makes factions.